Hindus and Muslims in Subcontinent: 1206-1707=501 years. Muslims and Jews in Palestine: 638-1917=1297 years. Jews and Muslims coexisted much longer than the Muslims and Hindus. If Muslims as a minority could not stand the Hindu majority ruling upon them with a different set of faiths and beliefs and an inherent disagreement and denial of their faith for any longer than 501 years, then lets ask my other Muslim brothers and sisters that how do they expect Jews to tolerate us as a majority government over them for 1300 years, when we openly proclaim to slaughter them all at once after the British left?
November 15, 2007 at 12:26 am |
I hope you know the percentage of Jews living in Palestine in the early years of 20th century in comparasion to their percentage of lad they occupy. Their percentage wasn’t more than 10, or was it 20? And how much land do they occupy now? 80%? And occupying homes of people and throwing them outta their lands, you call that freedom?And what comparasion with Muslims of sub-continent are you talking about? Muslims were never gifted freedom by the imperialist lords of their time.
Fact remains, theat Israel had been and has been a terrorist and illegitimate country, and no justification can be provided for that!
April 4, 2008 at 11:08 pm |
You tripepd over your own trap my friend. “Now” is the keyword. You just made two generalizations about the jewish population, and the land they occupy “now.” If you’re considering their population back in 1948, might I remind you that Jerusalem, Golan Heights, Galilee sea, and the entire Gazan strip was not a part of Israel at all. All of these areas were occupied in wars that our own muslim brethren countries kept declaring on israel in 1948, in 1967 and in 1973. Jerusalem remained a part of Jordan until they attacked israel in 1967 and lost it. Gaza remained a part of Egypt until egypt attacked israel twice, lost it twice, got it back once, didnt get it back the second time until 2005. Golan remained a part of syria until they lost it in 1973. Your premise was, they “NOW” occupy more land than their percentage in 1948.
You see the irony here, my friend? According to the UN Census, The jewish population in 1946 in “Palestine” was about 33 percent. The land it started from, subtracting gaza, golan heights, galilee and jerusalem was lesser too, rite? If it still doesn’t help, here’s a chart.
VII. By Area: Arab / Jewish Population (2006)
B. Chart
Israel West Bank Gaza Strip Total
Jews 5,137,8001 255,6001 01 5,393,4001
Arabs 1,439,7001 2,460,4922 1,428,7572 5,328,949
Source: http://www.israelipalestinianprocon.org/populationpalestine.html#graph6